DIY Soapmaking – How to Make Cold Process Soap

DIY Cold Process Soapmaking

Handmade Honeysuckle Soap from Rebecca's Soap Delicatessen

Soapmaking can be a lot of fun and very rewarding. However, it’s not something to just jump right into without first some research and understanding of the process. Not only are there precautions that need to be taken when making cold process soaps, but a failed batch can be a very expensive lesson.

Because of the many dangers associated with soapmaking due to the use of lye – also known as sodium hydroxide – and the plethora of information to be had, I recommend that you carefully research the process before starting out on your own. Details on where to obtain additional information will be included within this article.

Soapmaking involves a chemical process in which sodium hydroxide (lye) reacts with oils to make soap. This process is called saponification. Because this process requires the use of lye, important safety precautions must be taken. Rubber gloves and safety glasses should be worn during the soapmaking process, and vinegar, which neutralizes the lye, should be kept on hand in case of an accidental spill or burn. In addition to the necessary safety equipment needed for your journey into making cold process soap, there is other required equipment you’ll need to get started.

First and foremost you will need to acquire lye. Because without lye, there is no soap. The main components to make a true bar of soap are fat(s) – such as oils and butters – and an alkali – more commonly known as lye. You should be able to find lye in the plumbing section of your hardware store, at a local chemical supply store, or online. For those just getting started and without the need for a 50lb. bag of lye available from chemical supply stores, you can buy Roebic Heavy Duty Crystal Drain Opener in 2lb. containers at Lowe’s stores. (It contains 100% sodium hydroxide also known as caustic soda.) Alternatively, Red Devil Lyecan be purchased online. The brand doesn’t really matter, but it must be 99% or more pure sodium hydroxide. (If you are local to Roanoke, VA you can purchase 50lb. bags of sodium hydroxide beads locally in 50lb. bags from ChemSolv. Just be sure to transfer your bag of lye to a plastic container or double garbage bag lined box that you can seal after opening.)

In addition to the lye, you’ll also need a large pot for mixing the soap. I recommend a large stainless steel pot. What type of pot you use is up to you, however, your pot cannot be aluminum. Lye reacts badly with aluminum so remember to never mix the two. You’ll also need an accurate scale to weigh your ingredients in either ounces or grams. You can use digital postal scale from an office supply store. Just be sure the scale is calibrated properly and can handle the amount of weight you will be using. You’ll also need a thermometer or two to measure the temps of your oils and lye solution. And, you’ll find that a stick blender- also known as an immersion blender – is your best friend in making soap. You can hand stir, but this method can take you hours over minutes and a stick blender also ensures even distribution of ingredients. And then of course there are the molds, soapmaking oils, and distilled water to be mixed with the lye.

There are several types of molds you can use to create cold process soap. You can purchase tray molds that are basically hard plastic molds that will create numerous bars of soap at once. These molds should be marked suitable for cold process soapmaking since the soap gets very hot during the saponification process. You can also easily build a mold from wood, with a bottom and four sides. This type of mold will produce a log of soap that you would then cut into slices. When using a wooden mold, you must line it with parchment paper to aid in easy removal of the soap. (Freezer paper is not a good idea as it melts to the soap and mold.) Lining your mold is sort of like wrapping a present except that you are wrapping the inside of the box rather than the outside. It takes some practice to get it right. The parchment should then be secured with tape to the mold. Alternatively, you can line your mold with plastic film or a plastic office sized garbage bag. Just be sure to tape the material to the top of the mold for easy removal. You can learn how to make your own wooden soap molds here. (You can also make silicone soap molds.)

Next, we’re on to oils. The soapmaking oils are an important part of your soap. The types of oils you use will determine the properties that your soap will have. For example, three of the most popular soapmaking oils, especially for beginners, are olive oil, coconut oil, and palm oil. The olive oil helps create a moisturizing bar with a stable lather; coconut oil produces a hard, cleansing bar with a fluffy lather; and palm oil makes for a hard bar with a stable lather. Each of these oils has its own SAP (or saponification) value which determines how much lye should be used in the soap recipe for saponification to occur in such a way that it makes soap. Too much lye and you have an unusable bar of soap. Not enough and you could end up with a really soft soap with excess oil. A great source for learning more about the saponification process and the properties of various soapmaking fats & oils is Susan Miller Cavitch’s book The Soapmaker’s Companion. Her book also contains a great troubleshooting section and several of her own recipes. When creating your own recipes for soap, there are also a lot of additional free resources to help you with this process. Lye calculators, for example, will automatically calculate the amount of lye you need in a recipe based on the amounts and types of oils you plan to incorporate into your recipe. You can find multiple links to lye calculators by conducting a google search. Although I like to use the lye calculator at Majestic Mountain Sage. It is good practice to always double check the amount of lye in a recipe with a lye calculator if you are unsure of its source.

Let’s get down to business!

So, I guess by now you’re wondering just what you do with all of that lye and oil and equipment. Well, I’ll tell you. You make soap! Your best bet is to start by preparing your mold so that it is ready when your soap is ready to be poured. You’ll also need to cut out cardboard that will fit over the top of your mold. The cardboard will be used to help insulate your soap after it is made. Once these steps are complete, you would then measure out your distilled water as called for in the recipe you are using.

Measuring distilled water for soapmaking

Measure the amount of distilled water called for in your recipe out in fluid ounces.

Pour your distilled water into containers

Pour your distilled water into a non aluminum container. (I like to use plastic pitchers.) Weigh your lye for your soap recipe

Next, measure out your lye. Be sure you have on all of your safety gear for this. Lye gets VERY hot, and chemical burns are never any fun. Be sure to have vinegar open and close by for any spills. For the lye, you will be weighing the amount needed with your scale. Place the container you’re using to measure the lye onto the scale, press tare to zero it out, then slowly pour the lye onto the scale until you reach the amount needed.

Pour the lye into the distilled water

Then slowly pour your lye into the water, never the other way around as it could result in a not so pleasant volcano effect. Stir your lye into the water with a plastic or wooden spoon until it dissolves. Now set it aside to cool. If you’re mixing the lye inside, keep it on the stove with the exhaust fan turned on and step away. Or allow it to cool outside to avoid the nasty fumes. Be sure there are no children or animals underfoot who could get hurt.

Weigh out your soapmaking oils

Next we’re on to the oils! While the lye is cooling, you can weigh and melt your oils. I normally melt my oils all together in a large pot on the stove at medium heat. You can also melt the oils separately in canning jars within a water bath. First, however, you must weigh your oils on the scale. Weigh each oil individually. Set your container on the scale, hit tare so it zeros the weight, then slowly add the oils to the container until you’ve reached the weight the recipe calls for.

Soapmaking oils melting in stainless steel pot on stove

Repeat this process for all oils and fats in your recipe. I usually start with the solids first so I am adding the liquids to the pot last. Stir the oils until they are completely melted, then remove from heat.

Adding lye-water to soapmaking oils

Once your lye has cooled to at least 120 degrees F, though I find I like to use my lye-water solution between 95 and 100 degrees F, you can generally begin pouring the lye-water into your oils. The temperature of the oils can vary depending on what the recipe you are using calls for, but the oils should not be hotter than the lye. If you aren’t sure how a recipe will react at higher temps, then mix at between 95-100 degrees F. (Refer to The Soapmaker’s Companion for information on why temperatures matter.) With your handy stick blender ready to go, very slowly pour the lye-water into the oils.

Mixing soap

Begin stirring with the stick blender on low. As the lye and oil begins to incorporate, you can switch the blender to high. Stir well, moving the blender all over the bottom of the pot and up through the soap mixture.

What soap looks like at trace

You will continue to stir until you reach what is known as trace. When the soap has reached trace, it will sort of look like cream of wheat or a custard. When you pull the blender through the soap, it should leave a line following it, and if you pull some of the soap up then drop it on the surface of the soap, the soap should be able to support that drop. Should you not reach trace, within 15 minutes, you can rest for about 15 minutes, then start mixing again. Some oils used in soapmaking are slower to trace. Olive oil, for example, can take a much longer time to trace than other oils unless it is mixed with other oils whose properties promote a quick trace.

You would stir in any additives you’d like to use in your soap, such as fragrance or collodial oatmeal, once your soap has reached a light trace where it is just barely leaving a trail or supporting a drop. Mix these in well, especially any essential or fragrance oils, so you won’t have any “hot spots” in your soap. Generally fragrance oils account for 3-6% of your soap, but be sure to follow manufacturer’s recommendations if they are available. Note that some fragrances and essential oils can accelerate trace. Once your additives have been thoroughly incorporated, you’re ready to pour your soap into its mold!

Pouring soap into the mold

Slowly pour your soap into the prepared mold. Drop the mold with the soap onto the counter several times to help remove any air bubbles.

Cover and insulate your soap molds

Next, cover the mold with cardboard. You may tape the cardboard down onto the molds if you like. Follow this step by placing several towels or a blanket over your covered mold. This helps to insulate your soap so that the saponification process can properly occur. Your soap should then remained covered for 24 hours.

Cutting loaf of soap into bars

Once your soap has been in the mold for 24 hours, you can then remove the soap from the mold and cut into bars. I generally discount the amount of water used so that my soap can immediately be cut into bars. If once you unmold your soap, however, and find that it is really soft, then you can wait another day or two before unmolding and/or cutting your soap into bars. Once the soap has been removed from the mold, you will then need to allow your soap to cure in order to completely finish the saponification process. This generally takes a period of 2- 3 weeks. If you’re setting your soap to dry on a flat surface, be sure to set it on top of parchment or freezer paper to keep the oils from seeping out of the soap into the surface of your drying space. You can also dry your soaps on a rack. Once the soap has cured you can then package it to share with your friends and family!

If you’d like to see photos of the entire cold process soapmaking method, I’ve added an album to my fan page on facebook. You can view it here.

Still have questions?

Not everyone has a successful soapmaking experience the first go around. So if you’re still cautious after all of your research, then I recommend finding a friend who makes soap to teach you the process.

Ready, set, go!

Looking for an easy recipe to get you started? Well, here ya go.

Basic Cold Process Soap Recipe

7.2 oz. coconut oil
16.2 oz olive oil
10.8 oz palm oil
1.8 oz. shea butter

12 fl oz. distilled water
4.9 oz lye

At trace:
2 oz. fragrance oil of choice or 1 oz. essential oil of choice

Follow your basic soapmaking instructions (above) for a great basic bar of soap with a creamy thick lather! This recipe will fit into one of my wooden loaf soap molds. (Instructions on how to make a loaf soap mold here.)

Remember, if you are ever substituting an oil for another oil in a recipe, you must recalculate the recipe to get the correct amount of lye needed since different oils & fats have different SAP values. Never make a substitution without completing this crucial step.

Recommended Suppliers:

Mountain Rose Herbs
Bulk organic herbs, undiluted therapeutic quality essential oils, and bulk ingredients for soapmaking. They also carry a nice line of bottles, jars, and containers for packaging.

Natural Soap Making Kit
A natural soapmaking kit for beginners with all the ingredients you need to make your first batch of cold process soap including the lye. The box it comes in doubles as a mold.

Wholesale Supplies Plus
Large supplier of wholesale soapmaking supplies and cosmetic materials. Free shipping on everything with a low $30 minimum order.

Nature’s Garden
Wholesale candle and soap supplies with large selection of affordable, quality fragrance oils. Buy any 5 1lb. fragrance oils and get $1 off per container.

Soapmaking Resources & References:

Lye Calculator I
Lye calculator from Bramble Berry.

Lye Calculator II
Lye Calculator from Majestic Mountain Sage.

Lye Calculator III
Pine Meadows lye calculator.

Lye Calculator IV
An advanced soap calculator from Soap Calc designed to help you create the perfect soap recipe by giving you the chemical makeup and properties your ingredients will have in the finished product.

Weight Conversion & Percentage Calculator
Hate math? Now you can easily figure out what percentage of ingredients your recipe contains and easily create changes and re-formulate to suit you! Great for calculating lotions, fragrance and essential oils, etc. And now you can convert units of weight and temperatures too!

Properties of Soapmaking Oils
This chart is for looking up various fats and oils to see what characteristics they give your soap.

Non-Comodogenic Chart
This chart may help when formulating blends that are to be used on the face.

FDA Cosmetics Handbook
Regulations, Guidance, and Resources.

Herbal Infusion
Herbal Infusion Techniques for using infusions in soapmaking.

Understanding Oxides, Micas & Ultramarines
The following article was inspired by a reader’s question concerning the differences between oxides, micas, ultramarines and colorants and when to use which one.

How to Re-size a Batch of Cold Process Soap
Learn how to re-size any cold process soap recipe to suit your needs by making it either larger or smaller.

Soap Troubleshooting Chart
Cold Process Soaps Troubleshooting Chart.

How to Line a Wooden Soap Mold
This series of pictures will illustrate how we make the liner used to line the wooden soap mold, and how we make the cardboard form used to shape the liner paper.

Soapmaking colours/colors from herbs and spices
Herbs and spices for coloring CP (Cold Process) and HP (Hot Process) soap.

How to Make a Wood Loaf Soap Mold
Learn how to make a loaf wooden soap mold that yields 10-12 bars as well as where to source lye and how to line a wooden soap mold.

How to Make A Loaf Soap Cutter
Tutorial for making a loaf soap cutter to cut your soap loaves into evenly sized bars.

Ingredients recognized as safe by the FDA
Substances generally recognized as safe for use.

Soap Crafting
A modern book on how to make cold process homemade soaps, this book by renowned Soap Queen, Anne-Marie Faiola, contains easy to understand information, step-by-step photographs of thirty-one soap recipes and the process as well as tutorials on advanced soapmaking techniques such as swirling, funnel pours and embedding.

The Soapmaker’s Guide to Marketing Soap Online
This ebook by established author, Lisa Maliga, offers insight into the world of a homemade soap business for beginners. It includes questions to ask to see if you’re ready to sell your homemade soaps, how to set up a shop, pricing and labeling guidelines, avoiding scams, getting found, where to buy supplies and more.

DIY Ideas for Soap Labels
Learn how to create your own non-conventional soap labels and get some inspiration for making your own.

How to Make Soap with Circle Embeds
Learn how to make decorative cold process soaps with circles embedded within each bar.

Cold Process Goat Milk Soapmaking Tips
Learn how to make homemade goats milk soap the easy way without having to worry about prepping your goat milk in the freezer first to get it to that slushy ice stage or worrying about it curdling with my simple tutorial!

How to Hand Stamp Soaps
Learn how to decorate your homemade cold process soap bars with either hand carved or store bought stamps.

Cold Process Soap Recipes
A collection of handmade cold process soap recipes with instructions and photographs of the finished soaps.

Article and photos © Rebecca’s Soap Delicatessen

Comments

  1. Good post and great resources! I’d just like to add that if you use distilled ice cubes (at about 50% of your water weight) you won’t have to wait for your lye water to cool.

    Happy soaping!

  2. Wow! Super informative and interesting. Thank you!

  3. Is their something other then lye that I could use?

  4. Where do you get lye?

  5. When lining molds, freezer paper, with shiney side towards the soap, is actually ideal. Also, a heavy duty trashbag works wonders. Parchment or waxed papers, on the other hand, *will* result in a stuck on, messy mess.

  6. Thank you for this blog.

  7. Allie, I had freezer paper stick but never parchment paper and I used it for years. Perhaps the brand of parchment paper makes a difference. I have found trash bags the easiest and quickest though!

    Unknown, you cannot make soap without lye. I have suggestions of where to buy lye located within the article.

  8. Amazing post! Thanks so much for all these links. Great resources. I’m still afraid to try, though. Can you come over and walk me through it? ;=)

  9. Amazing! I was always curious about soap making. Never looked it up though.Thanks for sharing! And that soap looks so pretty.

  10. I have been reading everything I can find about soap. I want to make my own lye and make soap. I found out how to make lye, I have been looking for a recipe for the whole process. All from scratch. Just incase…someone needs to know how. Thanks if you can help. :)

  11. Makes me appreciate those specialty soaps at craft fares even more.

  12. Anonymous says:

    Just made my first batch of soap! thanks for the help!

  13. You are so welcome! Glad I could help!

  14. Anonymous says:

    I find it wonderful that, while you make a living of making soaps, you are still generously spreading tutorials and tips for us to make our own. Thank you so much!
    Isabelle, Quebec, Can.

  15. You’re welcome! Thanks for visiting!

  16. Love your site! I asked someone why their grandma put ashes in their soap and got a link to your site as a response. Learning so much. Thank you for all the great details!!!! :D

  17. Great info. I am just learning, and i mean a newbe. Could you give me the recipe for the beautiful yellow and blue soap in your picture at the top? also, how did you get the colors into the holes in the green and yellow soap. very cool!!! Have never seen that before. Thank you so much for all your help. And I apprecieate all you have posted on this great website!

    • The blue and yellow soap was made in layers. I poured half of my soap with a honeysuckle fragrance (light yellow on bottom) with no color, then in the other half I add yellow oxide pigment powder and stirred in pieces of blue colored soap made previously that I’d cut into cubes then poured it on top of the first layer. Which soap are you referring to that has holes with green and yellow?

  18. Thanks for all the great info. I really want to try making my own cp soap, however all the recipes I find have coconut oil. I have a severe coconut allergy. Is there a good beginners coconut oil free recipe?

  19. What does it mean when you say “I generally discount the amount of water used so that my soap can immediately be cut into bars.”? I don’t see any other instructions in the tutorial that discusses how to calculate how much water to use, am I missing something?

    • Some soap calcs like the one at Magestic Mountain Sage give a water range to use. Generally I use water right in between this suggestion. However, if you need to package bars right away you can use the lowest acceptable amount of water required. Other soap calcs give you the max suggested water or an average. It just depends on what calc you are using and what you looking to do with the soap when unmolded. You’d want to use more water if you are rolling the soap into soap balls and less if you need to be able to package your soaps sooner or don’t have space while the soaps are curing to leave them out to let the excess liquid evaporate. Once you get into research or using the different soap calcs this is something you may come across which is why I mention it. However, including everything in one short tutorial is impossible which is why I recommend doing additional research and purchasing an in depth book or two.

  20. I’ve been researching soap making and am about to start buying my supplies. I love your step by step instructions with pics. I was wondering if you use tallow in addition to oils? I have “The Complete Soap Maker” by Norma Coney and she always uses tallow in her recipes. Just wanted to get your thoughts on tallow. :) Thanks!

    • I never use tallow as I don’t use animal fats only vegetable fats in my recipes. I have heard that tallow soaps can smell pretty bad while you’re making them, but the scent tones down as it cures.

  21. great, informative tutorial. I’ve been considering making soap for a while, just wasn’t sure how to get started. Thanks for sharing!

  22. Monique R says:

    Rebecca, what turned the ingredients pink? It’s very pretty, but I didn’t see where you said you added any colorants.

  23. Hi! Love the website! It’s been most helpful. However, I have a small issue which is basically formulating my own recipe. The ingredients that I have on hand are aging & I need to use them quickly. But frankly, I don’t know what I’m doing. Haha! I’m still a rookie. What I have are…
    Olive oil, sunflower oil, coconut oil, castor oil, grape seed oil, jojoba oil, avocado oil, cocoa butter, Shea butter, bees wax, bentonite clay & essential oils.
    I’d prefer to use what I already have before buying other additives so that these do not go to waste.
    Any suggestions?

    Appreciate it!

    • If you visit the supplier’s website – or even Wholesale Supplies Plus – they will give you the recommended percentage of each oil you’re using. Use this to help give you a starting point for developing your recipes. Typically olive oil is used 30%-60%. Coconut oil I typically use at 20% but don’t recommend going over 30% as it’s cleansing in soap and will strip too many natural oils at higher percentages if using for bathing. Butters are typically used at 3-5% though I’ve strayed from this and used up to 10%. Just be aware of how it will impact the soap. I generally use clays at 3% of oil weight and eo’s at 1-2% of oil weight. Also if you use the lye calc at soapcalc.net it will tell you if you’re recipe falls within recommended percentages for all of the various soap properties. Determine the weight of the oils for your batch then multiply this amount by each of the percentage for each oil you want to use. ie. 36oz. of total oil weight for 30% olive oil would be 36 x .3 = 10.8 oz. of olive oil. Soapcalc however starts with the most water you should use so I recommend reducing the water to % of oils to 34-35%. Or run your final recipe through the lye calc at Brambleberry because that particular lye calc hits the water percentage at pretty much perfect.

  24. Chad Kendall says:

    Hello, I am just wondering how much soap I would have using your Basic Cold Process Soap Recipe? with the amounts of each ingredient that you give?

    Thank you

    Chad

  25. I love how nicely you’ve broken down all the steps. One major question I have is how do you know how many ounces of OILS to use? I see that you’ve listed websites that tell you how much lye to use, but what if you’re thinking backwards? For example, I have a silicone mold that can hold 4-6 pounds of soap. I know that I want to use: olive oil, sunflower seed oil, and grapeseed oil. So, before I determine how much lye, how do I know how much olive oil, sunflower, and grapeseed oil to use to make about 4 pounds of soap? Are they any websites that tell you how much oils to use before determining the lye and water?

  26. thanks for the sharing!! as a soup molde I use a milk/juice tetrapak, cutting the top part

  27. I prefer a anti odor soap till now, but suddely I’m finding a shortage of that particular product. I just came across this interesting term “homemade soaps”. Curious about the thought of making a soap for my use I tried to dig-in deeper and here I am.
    BTW what is “superfatted”, thou I was not able to understand what I’m calculating, just put some numbers and I got this result. Lye Calculator Results: A solid soap, measured in grams superfatted by 0%

Speak Your Mind

*

CommentLuv badge